.
POSTS BY SUBJECT
Labels
- ''ESTONIA'' (15)
- "Hindenburg" (2)
- “Yom Kippur” War (1)
- 2008 Mumbai attacks (12)
- 2017 Barcelona attacks (1)
- 2017 Westminster attack (1)
- 20th_Century (3)
- 7/7 London bombings (38)
- 911 (393)
- A.H.M. RAMSAY (2)
- Abu Ghraib (1)
- ADL (2)
- ADOLF_HITLER (23)
- ADVENTURE (1)
- Affirmative Action (1)
- Afghanistan (7)
- AFRICA (50)
- African Origins (1)
- Agriculture (3)
- AIDS (25)
- Al Azhar University (1)
- Alain de Benoist (15)
- Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (34)
- Alexander Dugin (1)
- Alois Irlmaier (1)
- Alt-Right (1)
- AMAZONIA (3)
- America (5)
- American Islamization (21)
- American Universities (2)
- American_Indian (1)
- AMISH (1)
- Ancient Egypt (1)
- ANCIENT_CIVILISATIONS (2)
- Angels (1)
- Animal_Rights (6)
- ANTEDILUVIAN_CIVILISATION (15)
- Anthony Blunt (1)
- Anthony Ludovici (3)
- ANTHROPOLOGY (8)
- Anti-Semitism (4)
- anti-White (4)
- Anti-White Attitudes (8)
- Anti-White Racism (1)
- Antifa (4)
- Apartheid (1)
- AR. LEESE (4)
- ARCHAEOLOGY (3)
- Argentina (1)
- Armenia (4)
- Armenian Genocide (1)
- Art (15)
- Arthur Koestler (1)
- Astronomy (30)
- ATHEISM (1)
- AUSTRALIA (5)
- AUSTRIA (2)
- Ayaan Hirsi Ali (4)
- Baha'i faith (1)
- BALI (1)
- Balkans (4)
- Bangladesh (2)
- banned_weapons (1)
- Barbarossa (2)
- Barcelona Attack (1)
- BELGIUM (4)
- Benjamin Freedman (1)
- BENJAMIN SOLARI PARRAVICINI (11)
- Beslan (1)
- Bill Clinton (1)
- Biological Warfare (2)
- Black America (2)
- BLACK RACE (14)
- Black students (1)
- BLOOD PASSOVER (12)
- BOLSHEVIK REVOLUTION (16)
- Book purge (1)
- Boycottage (1)
- Brainwashing (1)
- BRAZIL (1)
- BREXIT (1)
- Brigitte Gabriel (1)
- British politics (3)
- Buddhism (5)
- California (1)
- Cambodia (8)
- CANADA (12)
- CANCER (40)
- Carolina bays (1)
- Celebrities (1)
- Celebrities-Show Business (3)
- Cell Phone towers (6)
- Censorship in Europe (7)
- Central Europe (1)
- CENTRAL_ASIA (1)
- Central/South America (1)
- Ch. Bollyn (29)
- Charles Socarides (1)
- Charles Tart (8)
- Charlie Hebdo (1)
- Che Guevara (2)
- CHEMTRAILS (15)
- CHINA (13)
- Christian Zionism (1)
- CHRISTIANISM (46)
- CHRISTIANISM in EUROPE (2)
- Churchill (7)
- CINEMA (2)
- Circumcision (9)
- CLIMATE (8)
- Climate Change (9)
- cluster bombs/mines (2)
- COLD_FUSION (2)
- COLONIALISM (1)
- Colonization of Europe (39)
- Commerce (1)
- Communism (50)
- COMMUNIST CRIMES (1)
- CONGO (5)
- Consciousness (9)
- Conservatives (1)
- Conspiracies (8)
- Consumerism (1)
- contemporary society (13)
- COPTS (2)
- CoronaVirus (13)
- Cosmogony (1)
- COVID (2)
- Crime (5)
- Criminal_Sciense (1)
- CRIMINALITY (4)
- Croatia (1)
- crop circles (5)
- CUBA (16)
- Cultural Marxism (14)
- Czech Republic (1)
- DARFUR (3)
- Dark Ages (1)
- Dead Sea Scrolls (1)
- Death penalty in ISLAM (1)
- Death-Bed Visions (1)
- DECADANT_ART (1)
- Deir Yassin (8)
- Democracy (1)
- DENMARK (4)
- Depleted uranium (6)
- DIAMOND CARTELS (1)
- DIANA (10)
- DIETRICH ECKART (1)
- DILUVIUM (5)
- Disney (2)
- DOGS (1)
- Donald TRUMP (7)
- Dönmeh (1)
- Doppelgangers (1)
- Dresden (6)
- DRUG ADDICTION (1)
- E.U. (13)
- Eastern Europe (3)
- ECHELON (1)
- ECONOMY (15)
- EDUCATION (4)
- Egypt (12)
- Eisenhower (4)
- El Inglés (2)
- Elie Wiesel (1)
- Elite_Child_Sex_Rings (16)
- Elizabeth Taylor (1)
- ENERGY (9)
- Enoch Powell (1)
- environmentalism (11)
- Ernst Zundel (1)
- ethnicity and nationality (1)
- ETHNOLOGY/ANTHROPOLOGY (4)
- EUROPE viz. ISLAM (19)
- Europe's Energy Crisis (1)
- EUROPE's FUTURE (23)
- European Parliament (2)
- EUROPEAN UNION (14)
- EUROPEAN_IDENTITY (4)
- Eustace Mullins (10)
- Evidence for the Afterlife (2)
- EVOLUTION (9)
- EXPLORATIONS (1)
- Ezra Pound (1)
- Facebook (1)
- FALSE_HISTORY (2)
- Fascism (4)
- Fashion industry (1)
- FATIMA (9)
- Female Genital Mutilation (2)
- FEMINISM (19)
- FINLAND (3)
- Fjordman (9)
- Flight 007 (1)
- Fluoride (1)
- Food (11)
- FRANCE (38)
- FRANCE viz. ISLAM (10)
- Francis P. Yockey (5)
- Frankfurt School (2)
- Franklin D. Roosevelt (6)
- freedom of speech (1)
- Fukushima (2)
- G7 (1)
- Gas chambers (1)
- gay marriage (1)
- Gaza (1)
- Geert Wilders (11)
- GENDERISM (1)
- genetically modified organisms (GMO) (8)
- Georges Bensoussan (2)
- German National Socialism (14)
- GERMANY (53)
- GERMANY viz. ISLAM (10)
- Gilad Atzmon (14)
- Giulio Meotti (2)
- Global warming (2)
- Globalism (5)
- Great Britain (67)
- Great Pyramid (16)
- Great Reset (1)
- GREECE (2)
- GREENPEACE (3)
- Guatemala (1)
- Guillaume Faye (2)
- Gulag (3)
- Gulf War (1)
- Gulf War Syndrome (1)
- Gun control (1)
- Guylaine Lanctot (2)
- HAARP (10)
- Hans Günther (8)
- Harry Potter (1)
- Hate Group (1)
- HEALTH (114)
- HEMP (1)
- Henry Makow (2)
- Hidden History (15)
- HIDDEN HYPNOSIS TECHNIQUES (1)
- Hiroshima (5)
- Historical Review (67)
- History_of_IDEAS (3)
- HMS Hampshire (3)
- Hollow Earth (22)
- Hollywood (12)
- Holocaust (140)
- HOLODOMOR_1932-33 (17)
- Homosexuality (9)
- Horst Mahler (4)
- Howard Hughes (1)
- Human Equality (2)
- HUMAN_ORIGINS (2)
- HUMAN_RIGHTS (3)
- Humanitarian politics (1)
- Humorous (1)
- HUNGARY (2)
- HYPERBOREA (7)
- IAN STEVENSON (13)
- ICELAND (1)
- Image of Guadalupe (2)
- Immigration (29)
- IMPORTANT (4)
- INDIA (24)
- IndoEuropean (12)
- Indonesia (5)
- INFECTIOUS DISEASES EPIDEMICS (1)
- Infrasound Weapons (1)
- Intellectual_freedom (1)
- Intelligence (21)
- Intelligent design (8)
- International Criminal Tribunal (3)
- INTERNET (1)
- INTERRACIAL_RELATIONS (1)
- INTIMIDATION (4)
- INVENTIONS (3)
- IQ (4)
- IRAN (12)
- Iranian regime violence (1)
- IRAQ (22)
- IRAQ_war (11)
- IRELAND (5)
- Irish savant (3)
- ISLAM (347)
- Islam in Europe/America (100)
- ISLAM in RUSSIA (1)
- ISLAM propagandists (5)
- ISLAMIST INTIMIDATION (27)
- ISLAMIST_VIOLENCE (47)
- ISLAMIZATION OF EUROPE (92)
- Islamophobia (7)
- ISRAEL (128)
- Israel Shamir (1)
- Israel Supreme Court (1)
- ISRAEL-ARAB RELATIONS (11)
- ISRAEL's_ATOMIC_BOMB (4)
- ISRAEL/EU RELATIONS (1)
- ITALY (7)
- J.Kaminski (4)
- Japan (2)
- Jewish History (1)
- Jewish Question (1)
- JEWS (119)
- JEWS in GERMANY (1)
- JEWS in USA (1)
- JEWS/ISRAEL-USA_relations (52)
- JFK Assassination (40)
- JFK/RFK (2)
- Jihad (20)
- Jo Cox (6)
- Joe Sobran (4)
- John Bryant (16)
- John Lear (3)
- Jon Rappoport (1)
- Journalists (2)
- Judith Bergman (2)
- Julius Evola (37)
- Jyllands-Posten newspaper (1)
- Kafirs (1)
- Karl Marx (1)
- Katie King (1)
- Katyn (11)
- Kennedys (1)
- KENYA (1)
- Kevin MacDonald (41)
- KHAZARs (1)
- Knut Hamsun (1)
- Kurdistan (3)
- KURDS (3)
- Lasha Darkmoon (15)
- Laurel Canyon (4)
- Layla Anwar (4)
- LEBANON (3)
- LEFT (20)
- LGBT (3)
- Liberalism (1)
- Lord Kitchener (4)
- Lord Northcliff (1)
- Lost Civilisations (2)
- Lost Technology (1)
- Louis XVII (1)
- LYDDA (1)
- MADELEINE McCANN (4)
- Magic (1)
- Magnesium (7)
- Mahathir (1)
- Mahatma Gandhi (4)
- Malaysia (2)
- Manchester Terror Attack (1)
- Manchester terrorist attack (11)
- Manipulation (69)
- MAPS (1)
- Mark Weber (10)
- Mass immigration_Multiculturalism (57)
- Mass_Media (5)
- Mass-Psychology (4)
- Massacres (1)
- May-June 2017 London Jihadist attacks (4)
- Medjugorje apparitions (3)
- METEMPSYCHOSIS (17)
- MEXICO (1)
- MH370 (2)
- MIDDLE EAST (47)
- Military Tribunal at Nuremberg (11)
- MIND CONTROL (26)
- MONEY-Banking (8)
- Monsanto (9)
- Moon Landing (1)
- Morality (1)
- Mormonism (1)
- Mortacracy (6)
- MULTICULTURALISM (14)
- MUSIC MAFIA (2)
- Muslim Brotherhood (5)
- Muslim Honor Killings (1)
- Muslim Persecution of Christians (3)
- MUSLIMS IN EUROPE (81)
- Mussolini (3)
- Mysterious (69)
- Mysterious_SKY (1)
- Nathuram Godse (3)
- National Memorial and Arboretum (1)
- Native Americans (1)
- NAZISM (1)
- Neapolis (1)
- NESSIE (17)
- Netherlands (10)
- New World Order (4)
- NEW_ZEALAND (1)
- NGOs (3)
- Nicolai Sennels (1)
- NIGERIA (1)
- NO-borders (1)
- no-go zones (2)
- NOAM CHOMSKY (4)
- Nonie Darwish (14)
- North Africa (3)
- NORWAY (5)
- Norway massacre (4)
- NUCLEAR (12)
- Nutrition (20)
- Obama (2)
- Occult Symbols (21)
- Oklahoma City bombing (7)
- OLYMPIC_GAMES (13)
- OPINION (9)
- Orel_Yiftachel (5)
- Organized Jewry (15)
- P. Buchanan (26)
- PACIFISM (1)
- PAEDOPHILIA (15)
- Paganism (2)
- PAKISTAN (3)
- PALESTINE 1944-1948 (1)
- Palestinians (19)
- PARIS (1)
- Patrice Lumumba (1)
- PATRICIA HEARST (2)
- Patton (2)
- Paul Craig Roberts (1)
- Paul Weston (9)
- PEARL HARBOR (1)
- Persecuted Christians (7)
- PERSONALITIES (1)
- Philosophy of Civilization (1)
- Photographic_Archive (1)
- Photography (2)
- Physics (9)
- POLAND (5)
- POLAR REGIONS (30)
- Poliomyelitis (8)
- Political Thought (56)
- Pollution (3)
- Polynesia (25)
- Pope Benedict (1)
- Popular Culture (2)
- POPULATION FORECAST (4)
- Populism (1)
- Pornography (2)
- PORTUGAL (6)
- Post-War Politics (1)
- PREHISTORY (28)
- propaganda (5)
- Prophecies (14)
- Psychedelics (66)
- PSYCHIATRY (10)
- Psychical Research (124)
- Psychology (6)
- Putin (1)
- QATAR (4)
- Qater-France Relations (1)
- QUEBEC (1)
- Queen Victoria (1)
- R.R.Rife (10)
- Race (135)
- RACE MIXING (2)
- Racism (5)
- RAPE statistics (1)
- RED_Alert (4)
- Religion (27)
- René Guénon (1)
- REPUBLICAN PARTY (1)
- Revilo Oliver (16)
- Richard Dawkins (1)
- Riyadh address to the Muslim world (1)
- Robert Faurisson (1)
- Rockefellers (1)
- Roger Garaudy (6)
- ROMA (1)
- Roman Catholic Church (12)
- ROMANIA (1)
- Ron Paul (8)
- Rotherham Sex scandal (1)
- Rudolph Hess (1)
- Ruling_by_CORRUPTION (14)
- RUSSIA (14)
- RUSSIAN REVOLUTION (1)
- RWANDA (31)
- S. H. Pearson (1)
- Sabra-Shatila massacre (10)
- SALMAN RUSHDIE (1)
- Sandy Hook (1)
- Sanskrit (1)
- SAUDI ARABIA (7)
- Savitri Devi (27)
- Scandinavia (1)
- SCIENCE (45)
- Secret Military Technology (14)
- Secret weapons (10)
- Sedition Trial (1)
- SERBIA (1)
- sexual freedom (6)
- Sexualization of Culture (6)
- SICK SOCIETIES (5)
- Sinister sites (11)
- Skepticism (1)
- Slave trade (1)
- Slavoj Zizek (1)
- SOCIALISM (10)
- SOCIOLOGY (1)
- SOUTH AFRICA (11)
- Space/Apollo_Hoax (54)
- SPAIN (6)
- Spanish Civil War (1)
- Spengler (6)
- Spirituality (1)
- Srebrenica (1)
- STALINISM (1)
- State_criminality (9)
- Steganography (16)
- Steven Yates (7)
- STRANGE SOUNDS (4)
- Subterranean_world (10)
- SUDAN (2)
- SUPERNATURAL (16)
- Surveillance (1)
- SWASTIKA (33)
- Swaziland (1)
- SWEDEN (24)
- Switzerland (2)
- SYRIA (9)
- SYRIAN WAR (1)
- TAIWAN (1)
- Taj Mahal (13)
- Ted Kaczynski (1)
- Terrorism (47)
- TESLA (6)
- The 1001 Club (1)
- The Celts (1)
- The Cultural Integration Initiative (1)
- THE END OF WHITE RACE (29)
- The Great Flood (8)
- The Irish Savant (9)
- The Mass Rape of German Women by the Red Army (1)
- The Nuremberg Trials (5)
- The plutonium injections (4)
- the Wealth of Nations (2)
- Theo van Gogh (1)
- Thomas Dalton (3)
- Thought of the Right (64)
- Thought-control (3)
- TITANIC (72)
- tolerance law (1)
- Tom Kawczynski (1)
- Tommy Robinson (1)
- Torture (1)
- Tradition (5)
- Transatlantic Slave Trade (1)
- Transcendent Experience (6)
- Transgenderism (2)
- TRUMP (2)
- TRUMP _Administration (3)
- Tunguska (1)
- Tunisia (2)
- TURKEY (9)
- TWA flight 800 (1)
- U.S.A. (142)
- U.S.A. ARMY CRIMINALITY (18)
- U.S.A. Foreign policy (14)
- U.S.A. Military (2)
- U.S.A._HISTORY (2)
- U.S.A._POLITICS (16)
- U.S.A._SOCIETY (9)
- U.S.A.-CIA (16)
- U.S.A.-Power Structure (11)
- U.S.S. Liberty (7)
- UFOs (166)
- Ukraine (18)
- United Church of Christ (1)
- United Nations (3)
- UNKNOWN_EARTH (2)
- USA (20)
- USA Black Crime Problem (4)
- USA criminality (1)
- USA DEMOCRATS (4)
- USA Education (1)
- USA_Press (5)
- USA/2020 (25)
- USA/USSR_relations (2)
- USS San Francisco (1)
- USSR (55)
- Uvalde massacre (1)
- Vaccination (1)
- VATICAN (12)
- Vatican II (3)
- VELIKOVSKY (2)
- Vernon Coleman (14)
- Victimism (1)
- Voynich_manuscript (15)
- Vulture_Capitalism (1)
- WAFA SULTAN (1)
- War Crimes (36)
- WAR in Ukraine (3)
- water (2)
- Wayne MADSEN (2)
- WEST (17)
- WEST viz. ISLAM (14)
- WEST/ISLAM Relations (23)
- Western Masochism (3)
- WESTERN_ELITES (6)
- WHITE Ethnocentrism (3)
- White Guilt (4)
- White phosphorous (1)
- White Race (15)
- WHITE self-hatred (4)
- WILD_LIFE (1)
- Wilhelm Reich (4)
- William Gough (10)
- wind farms (1)
- Wm F. Koch (8)
- Women in Islam (9)
- World Wildlife Fund (8)
- WORLD_ORDER (56)
- WORLD's FUTURE (1)
- WWI (6)
- WWII (97)
- WWII Aftermath (42)
- WWIII (1)
- Younger Dryas Ice Age (4)
- Youth of Europe (1)
- Yugoslavia (9)
- Zimbabwe (1)
- ZIONISM (13)
POSTS ABOUT CHRISTIANISM's EARLY HISTORY ARE MAINLY ON THE "JESUS PUZZLE" PAGE
---------------------------------------------
Sunday, February 19, 2012
The Unseemly Spectacle of Patriot Turf Wars
———-
IMPORTANT -"Sovereignty and the UFO"
Alexander Wendt and Raymond Duvall
"Sovereignty and the UFO"
Thursday, January 19, 2006
12:00 p.m.
Mershon Center for International Security Studies
Wendt&Duvall, Draft 1: p.1
Alexander Wendt is the Ralph D. Mershon Professor of International Security Studies at the Mershon Center, and Raymond Duvall is Professor of Political Science and Associate Director of the Interdisciplinary Center for the Study of Global Change/MacArthur Interdisciplinary Program on Global Change, Sustainability, and Justice at the University of Minnesota. They gave a talk entitled “Sovereignty and the UFO” at the Mershon Center, addressing the puzzle of why it is that modern states do not take Unidentified Flying Objects seriously.
Wendt and Duvall offer what they call an “epistemology of UFO ignorance” to explain why modern states systematically resist the notion that extra-terrestrial life forms might both exist and travel to earth. They emphasized their militant agnosticism about whether UFOs really are extra-terrestrial, saying that they are interested only in how and why the ignorance is maintained.
They said that the authoritative public sphere discourages taking UFOs seriously, and that this is ignorance masquerading as knowledge. There has actually been little scientific research on the subject, meaning that we do not know whether or not UFOs exist. Lack of evidence for UFOs’ existence does not mean that they do not exist, Wendt and Duvall argued, and skepticism regarding UFOs – that extra-terrestrials would be unable to reach earth, that UFOs would land on the White House lawn, that we would know if UFOs had been on earth – is not sufficient. Instead, the burden of proof ought to lie with disproving their existence.
Wendt and Duvall explained why they would expect UFOs to be taken seriously. First, if UFOs were found to prove the existence of extra-terrestrial life, this would be the most important event in world history. Second, aliens pervade popular culture, making it clear that people are interested in the phenomenon of UFOs. Third, states have historically been very willing to label things security threats, because the presence of more security threats increases states’ power in order to deal with them. Last, natural scientific curiosity would seem to make research about UFOs interesting and desirable. Despite all of this, very little is known about UFOs, and the modern state shows no signs of encouraging otherwise.
"Sovereignty and the UFO"
Thursday, January 19, 2006
12:00 p.m.
Mershon Center for International Security Studies
Wendt&Duvall, Draft 1: p.1
Alexander Wendt is the Ralph D. Mershon Professor of International Security Studies at the Mershon Center, and Raymond Duvall is Professor of Political Science and Associate Director of the Interdisciplinary Center for the Study of Global Change/MacArthur Interdisciplinary Program on Global Change, Sustainability, and Justice at the University of Minnesota. They gave a talk entitled “Sovereignty and the UFO” at the Mershon Center, addressing the puzzle of why it is that modern states do not take Unidentified Flying Objects seriously.
Wendt and Duvall offer what they call an “epistemology of UFO ignorance” to explain why modern states systematically resist the notion that extra-terrestrial life forms might both exist and travel to earth. They emphasized their militant agnosticism about whether UFOs really are extra-terrestrial, saying that they are interested only in how and why the ignorance is maintained.
They said that the authoritative public sphere discourages taking UFOs seriously, and that this is ignorance masquerading as knowledge. There has actually been little scientific research on the subject, meaning that we do not know whether or not UFOs exist. Lack of evidence for UFOs’ existence does not mean that they do not exist, Wendt and Duvall argued, and skepticism regarding UFOs – that extra-terrestrials would be unable to reach earth, that UFOs would land on the White House lawn, that we would know if UFOs had been on earth – is not sufficient. Instead, the burden of proof ought to lie with disproving their existence.
Wendt and Duvall explained why they would expect UFOs to be taken seriously. First, if UFOs were found to prove the existence of extra-terrestrial life, this would be the most important event in world history. Second, aliens pervade popular culture, making it clear that people are interested in the phenomenon of UFOs. Third, states have historically been very willing to label things security threats, because the presence of more security threats increases states’ power in order to deal with them. Last, natural scientific curiosity would seem to make research about UFOs interesting and desirable. Despite all of this, very little is known about UFOs, and the modern state shows no signs of encouraging otherwise.
Wendt and Duvall argued that the authoritative epistemology of UFO ignorance is necessary to maintain modern governance, because intelligent extra terrestrial life that can make itself known on earth is a threat to human-centered science and rule. They said that UFOs constitute a metaphysical threat to human power, making ignoring them the only alternative acceptable to modern states. They divided their argument into three parts.
First, they situated modern rule as “governmentality.” Governmentality is what Foucault describes as non-coercive rule, or power that functions not by violence or physical oppression but through control of knowledge. Both science and the state rest upon an anthropocentric metaphysics, whereby human conduct is all that matters. A regime of governmentality may also have a sovereign or coercive face, however, which deals with the physical threats that arise (but rarely).
Second, they discussed how that sovereign face functions. They said that there are sometimes physical threats to governmentality, and that, in these exceptional circumstances, the state must resort to coercive behavior.
Second, they discussed how that sovereign face functions. They said that there are sometimes physical threats to governmentality, and that, in these exceptional circumstances, the state must resort to coercive behavior.
Third, they said that the UFO poses not just a physical threat, to which a modern state could respond with its sovereign behavior, but also a metaphysical threat. Even if a UFO and its occupants had benign intentions, its unique otherness (in being non-human) would require a world government, united against the other, and this new universal sovereignty would replace the modern state as we know it.
Wendt and Duvall repeated that phenomena requiring exceptions to normal governmentality fall into two categories: physical (e.g. conquest) and existential or ontological threats (e.g. the existence of a non-human world that would extinguish the viability of individual nationally sovereign states). They said that the state cannot decide how to deal with UFOs as an exception, because even acknowledging their possible existence would call into question the state’s role as the sole securitizer, and this leaves only one option: the existence of UFOs must be denied.
They also noted that the study of UFOs, even if it were not actively discouraged politically, may be a difficult task. The UFO poses what they called a “threat of unknowability” to science, on several grounds. First, UFOs are random and seemingly unsystematic. Second, UFOs appear to violate the laws of physics, making them “impossible” per the laws of science that would be used to study them. Third, the UFO raises the possibility of a non-human subjectivity, making an understanding of UFOs potentially unassayable.
Wendt and Duvall said that modern states’ ignorance of UFOs need not be conscious, as conspiracy theories would suggest. States might unconsciously repress UFOs as taboo, so as not to reveal their existential insecurities. Wendt and Duvall identified four mechanisms by which states, whether consciously or unconsciously, authoritatively repress UFOs.
--First, epistemic authorities may simply announce that we know UFOs not to exist.
--Second, they may announce that UFOs do not and cannot constitute a security threat (on the grounds mentioned earlier, e.g. UFOs would not be able to reach earth, etc). These claims might be supported by secrecy, such as the non-reporting of cases or redactions from official reports.
--Third, they may denounce UFO research as inherently pseudo-science. They may do this by systematically denying federal funding to any grant proposal about such research, or by otherwise exerting pressure on scientists to self-censor to avoid ridicule.
--Last, epistemic authorities may practice pseudo-science, themselves. For example, the U.S. Air Force commissioned a report on UFOs in the late 1960s, and the panel undertaking the research was stacked with skeptics whose bias rendered their findings unscientific. Even while suffering from serious methodological flaws that biased findings against the existence of UFOs, the study had a 30% failure rate at explaining them. This failure rate hardly warranted the study’s summary, which declared that UFOs do not exist.
Ultimately, Wendt and Duvall characterized UFOs as a political problem first, rather than a scientific or sociological one. In order to address UFOs, the taboos against such research must be lifted. They said that once there is real scientific research underway, it should be possible for science and the state to diverge on the question of UFOs’ existence.
Wendt and Duvall repeated that phenomena requiring exceptions to normal governmentality fall into two categories: physical (e.g. conquest) and existential or ontological threats (e.g. the existence of a non-human world that would extinguish the viability of individual nationally sovereign states). They said that the state cannot decide how to deal with UFOs as an exception, because even acknowledging their possible existence would call into question the state’s role as the sole securitizer, and this leaves only one option: the existence of UFOs must be denied.
They also noted that the study of UFOs, even if it were not actively discouraged politically, may be a difficult task. The UFO poses what they called a “threat of unknowability” to science, on several grounds. First, UFOs are random and seemingly unsystematic. Second, UFOs appear to violate the laws of physics, making them “impossible” per the laws of science that would be used to study them. Third, the UFO raises the possibility of a non-human subjectivity, making an understanding of UFOs potentially unassayable.
Wendt and Duvall said that modern states’ ignorance of UFOs need not be conscious, as conspiracy theories would suggest. States might unconsciously repress UFOs as taboo, so as not to reveal their existential insecurities. Wendt and Duvall identified four mechanisms by which states, whether consciously or unconsciously, authoritatively repress UFOs.
--First, epistemic authorities may simply announce that we know UFOs not to exist.
--Second, they may announce that UFOs do not and cannot constitute a security threat (on the grounds mentioned earlier, e.g. UFOs would not be able to reach earth, etc). These claims might be supported by secrecy, such as the non-reporting of cases or redactions from official reports.
--Third, they may denounce UFO research as inherently pseudo-science. They may do this by systematically denying federal funding to any grant proposal about such research, or by otherwise exerting pressure on scientists to self-censor to avoid ridicule.
--Last, epistemic authorities may practice pseudo-science, themselves. For example, the U.S. Air Force commissioned a report on UFOs in the late 1960s, and the panel undertaking the research was stacked with skeptics whose bias rendered their findings unscientific. Even while suffering from serious methodological flaws that biased findings against the existence of UFOs, the study had a 30% failure rate at explaining them. This failure rate hardly warranted the study’s summary, which declared that UFOs do not exist.
Ultimately, Wendt and Duvall characterized UFOs as a political problem first, rather than a scientific or sociological one. In order to address UFOs, the taboos against such research must be lifted. They said that once there is real scientific research underway, it should be possible for science and the state to diverge on the question of UFOs’ existence.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)