Hollywood’s Agenda, and the Power Behind It
By Mark Weber
Text of address given at the “Hollywoodism” conference in Tehran, Iran, on Feb. 6, 2013
Last September, during my first visit to Iran, an incident occurred
that underscores the importance of our meeting here this week.
Perhaps eight of us -- men and women from several different countries
who were attending the “New Horizon” conference -- were sitting
together for a meal at a large, round table at the top of the Milad
Tower, high above central Tehran. As the conversation turned to customs
and lifestyles in our different countries, a younger Iranian in his 20s
remarked, almost in passing, that Americans are slender and thin. I was
surprised by this, and responded by saying that, by all accounts,
Americans are the most overweight people in the world. I asked him why
he thought Americans are slender and thin. Well, he replied, that’s how
they look in American movies.
Now, this young man was not stupid or foolish. And what people think
about the average weight of Americans is not a critically important
matter.
But his remark was another reminder of Hollywood’s tremendous,
global influence, and of how misleading its imagery can be.
-------
During one-on-one talks with Iranians, I’ve been surprised by how
many have a strangely idealized impression of the US and American
society that’s based on their viewing of American movies and television.
This is especially remarkable given that, in the United States at
least, we’re told that Iranians hate America. Actually, it seems that
often the most hostile view of the US and Americans is by people in
countries that are supposed “friends” of the US, and that a much more
positive view of the United States can sometimes be found in countries
that are supposed enemies of America.
If even many Iranians, whom one might suppose would be particularly
skeptical of Hollywood imagery and propaganda, can be so readily swayed
or misled by it, how much more easily influenced and misled might people
be in countries that are under the direct shadow of Washington, New
York and Hollywood.
Well, we certainly have our work cut out for us!
Everyone understands that American motion pictures and television,
and, more broadly, the US mass media, play an important role in shaping
the outlook, values and behavior, of many millions of people around the
world, especially, of course, in my homeland, the United States. But
even many of those who readily acknowledge this influence seem not to
fully comprehend the formidable power behind Hollywood, or the outlook
and agenda of those who wield that power.
Last September, during my first visit to Iran, I was a bit surprised
that at one session of the “New Horizon” conference, a few of the
participants objected to describing Hollywood as “Zionist controlled” or
“Zionist dominated.” The discussion became so heated that a special
session was scheduled to further debate this issue and, hopefully, to
reach a consensus on it. This question is not a peripheral or academic
one. An awareness of who holds power in Hollywood is essential for an
understanding of the outlook, ideology and agenda of those who wield
such great influence.
During a television interview in 1996, actor
Marlon Brando spoke
bluntly on this subject. He said:
“I am very angry with some of the Jews
... They know perfectly well what their responsibilities are ...
Hollywood is run by Jews. It’s owned by Jews, and they should have a
greater sensitivity about the issue of people who are suffering.” / 1
For making those remarks, Zionist voices in the US quickly and
severely denounced the veteran actor. He was sternly rebuked, for
example, by the “Anti-Defamation League,” one of the most powerful and
influential Jewish-Zionist groups in the US. The ADL called Brando’s
remarks a “slur.”
In fact, statements, at least by non-Jews, that affirm
Zionist or Jewish domination of Hollywood are routinely denounced by
the ADL and similar groups as groundless, “anti-Semitic,” and
intolerably offensive “hate” speech. / 2
But what’s the reality of the matter? Was Marlon Brando telling the
truth? How accurate is it to describe Hollywood -- and, more generally,
the US mass media -- as Jewish or Zionist controlled?
One of the most knowledgeable and seasoned observers of Hollywood is
Michael Medved, a well-known Jewish author and political commentator who
is also a prominent film critic. On this subject, he has written:
“It
makes no sense at all to try to deny the reality of Jewish power and
prominence in popular culture. Any list of the most influential
production executives at each of the major movie studios will produce a
heavy majority of recognizably Jewish names.” / 3
One person who has carefully studied this subject is Jonathan J. Goldberg, editor of the influential Jewish community weekly
Forward. In his 1996 book, entitled
Jewish Power, he wrote: / 4
“In a few key sectors of the media, notably among Hollywood studio
executives, Jews are so numerically dominant that calling these
businesses Jewish-controlled is little more than a statistical
observation ...
“Hollywood at the end of the twentieth century is still an industry
with a pronounced ethnic tinge. Virtually all the senior executives at
the major studios are Jews. Writers, producers, and to a lesser degree
directors are disproportionately Jewish -- one recent study showed the
figure as high as 59 percent among top-grossing films.
“The combined weight of so many Jews in one of America’s most
lucrative and important industries gives the Jews of Hollywood a great
deal of political power.”
Another person who has commented with some authority on this matter
is Joel Stein, a Jewish Hollywood producer, and a writer for
Time magazine and other periodicals. In a column that appeared in December 2008 in the
Los Angeles Times,
he wrote:
“As a proud Jew, I want America to know about our
accomplishment. Yes, we control Hollywood ... I don’t care if Americans
think we’re running the news media, Hollywood, Wall Street or the
government. I just care that we get to keep running them.” / 5
Several years ago, Bishop Desmond Tutu of South Africa, who was
awarded the 1984 Nobel Peace Prize, told an audience in Boston: "... You
know as well as I do that, somehow, the Israeli government is placed on
a pedestal [in the US], and to criticize it is to be immediately dubbed
anti-Semitic ... People are scared in this country, to say wrong is
wrong because the Jewish lobby is powerful -- very powerful." / 6
Bishop Tutu spoke the truth. Although Jews make up only about two or
three percent of the US population, they wield immense power and
influence — vastly more than any other ethnic or religious group.
As Jewish author and political science professor Benjamin Ginsberg has pointed out: / 7
“Since the 1960s, Jews have come to wield considerable influence in
American economic, cultural, intellectual and political life. Jews
played a central role in American finance during the 1980s, and they
were among the chief beneficiaries of that decade's corporate mergers
and reorganizations. Today, though barely two percent of the nation's
population is Jewish, close to half its billionaires are Jews. The chief
executive officers of the three major television networks and the four
largest film studios are Jews, as are the owners of the nation's largest
newspaper chain and the most influential single newspaper, The New York Times ... The role and influence of Jews in American politics is equally marked ...
“Jews are only three percent of the nation's population and comprise
eleven percent of what this study defines as the nation's elite.
However, Jews constitute more than 25 percent of the elite journalists
and publishers, more than 17 percent of the leaders of important
voluntary and public interest organizations, and more than 15 percent of
the top ranking civil servants.”
Two well-known Jewish writers, Seymour Lipset and Earl Raab, went into this in their 1995 book,
Jews and the New American Scene. They wrote: / 8
“During the last three decades Jews [in the United States] have made
up 50 percent of the top two hundred intellectuals ... 20 percent of
professors at the leading universities ... 40 percent of partners in the
leading law firms in New York and Washington ... 59 percent of the
directors, writers, and producers of the 50 top-grossing motion pictures
from 1965 to 1982, and 58 percent of directors, writers, and producers
in two or more primetime television series.”
This intimidating power is not a new or recent phenomenon. Thirty
years ago, the anti-Zionist Jewish American scholar Alfred M. Lilienthal
-- whom I knew well, and for whom I once worked -- dealt with this in
his detailed study, titled
The Zionist Connection. He wrote: / 9
“The extent and depth to which organized Jewry reached -- and reaches
-- in the U.S. is indeed awesome … The most effective component of the
Jewish connection is probably that of media control … Jews, toughened by
centuries of persecution, have risen to places of prime importance in
the business and financial world… Jewish wealth and acumen wields
unprecedented power in the area of finance and investment banking,
playing an important role in influencing U.S. policy toward the Middle
East … In the larger metropolitan areas, the Jewish-Zionist connection
thoroughly pervades affluent financial, commercial, social,
entertainment, and art circles.”
In 1972, during a private White House meeting, President Richard
Nixon and the Rev. Billy Graham, the nation's best-known Christian
evangelist, spoke together frankly about the Jewish grip on the media.
Their secretly recorded one-on-one conversation was not made public
until 30 years later.
During their talk, Graham said: "This stranglehold
has got to be broken or the country's going down the drain." The
President responded by saying: "You believe that?" Graham replied: "Yes,
sir." And Nixon said: "Oh, boy. So do I. I can't ever say that, but I
believe it." / 10
Even though President Nixon, supposedly the most powerful man in the
world, believed that America was, as he put it, "going down the drain"
unless what he regarded as the Jewish "stranglehold" on the US media is
broken, he was afraid to speak publicly about this matter. As powerful
as he was, President Nixon feared a power greater than his own.
A characteristic feature of unethical or illegitimate power is a
pattern of lies and deceit. For more than 70 years one of the main
pillars of Jewish Hollywood has been Metro Goldwyn Mayer. The familiar
roaring lion trademark of this great motion picture and television
production company appears at the beginning of MGM films. Around the
roaring lion of the trademark are the words, in Latin, of the MGM motto,
“Ars Gratia Artis,” which means “Art for the sake of art.” This motto
is supposed to suggest that, at least for Hollywood and MGM, film and
television productions are made, or should be made, only to promote art
or culture for its own sake.
In fact, this MGM motto -- this liberal watchword -- is a lie. For
MGM, as for all of Hollywood, “art”, or, more precisely, motion pictures
and television shows, are produced and marketed not for the sake of
“art” or “culture,” but rather, above all, for the sake of money, for
profits -- but also to promote the interests, ideology and goals of
those who control and run Hollywood. An important and socially harmful
consequence of Hollywood’s furious scramble for dollars is the
production of motion pictures and television shows aimed at the largest
possible markets, and which, therefore, often pander to a base cultural
level. That’s bad enough. But in addition, Hollywood has a long record
of turning out films that are made to further ideological, ethnic or
political goals.
A good example is “Exodus,” a 1960 epic about the founding of the
State of Israel. It’s based on a best-selling novel of the same name,
written by Leon Uris, an ardent Jewish Zionist. The film’s producer and
director was the Jewish immigrant, Otto Preminger. With a memorable,
soaring musical score, and starring such prominent actors as Paul Newman
and Eva Marie Saint, the film was enormously successful.
In the film, and in the book on which it was based, Jews are
portrayed as high-minded, sensitive, idealistic, resourceful and
courageous. The British are shown as cynical and rather ignorant. And
the Palestinian Arabs, insofar as they are depicted at all, are
portrayed as treacherous, cruel and murderous. For an entire generation
of Americans, including myself as a youth, along with millions in other
countries, the “Exodus” film was perhaps the single most important
factor in shaping our view of Zionism and the Palestine-Israel conflict.
During the second half of the last century, one of America’s most
popular entertainers was Steve Allen. He was also a gifted and noted
musician, composer and writer. In 1992 -- some twenty years ago -- he
said:
“Everyone -- left, right and middle -- is perfectly aware that we
are in a period of cultural and moral collapse. But some people don’t
want to concede that the popular media bear part of the responsibility.”
/ 11
Allen was right. Few people, I think, will dispute that Hollywood
has played a major role in lowering, even debasing, the cultural level
of the United States, and, to a certain extent, of much of the rest of
the world.
Michael Medved, the Jewish American author and film critic I
mentioned earlier, took a critical look at this issue in a
widely-discussed 1992 book titled
Hollywood vs. America. While
Hollywood continues to produce works of technical brilliance, dazzling
camera work, stunning special effects, impressive sets, skilled editing,
and creative writing, the great problem of America’s
cultural-entertainment center is what Medved calls a
“sickness of the
soul.”
Hollywood today, he says, is a “poison factory,” where what he
calls a “pattern of honoring ugliness “ has become “pervasive.” “The
most influential leaders of the entertainment industry,” Medved goes on,
demonstrate what he describes as a “preference for the perverse.” “One
of the symptoms of the corruption and collapse of our popular culture,”
he wrote, “is the insistence that we examine only the surface of any
piece of art or entertainment. The politically correct, properly liberal
notion is that we should never dig deeper -- to consider whether a
given work is true, or good, or spiritually nourishing -- or to evaluate
its impact on society at large.” / 12
Those who defend Hollywood, and the “American way of life,” will
sometimes argue that -- however base or perverse some Hollywood
productions may be -- they do not represent “official” or institutional
Hollywood. A distinction, they say, should be made between the few
admittedly deplorable productions -- a small number of “rotten apples”
-- on the one hand, and “official” or institutional Hollywood, on the
other. However valid this argument may be, there’s also no question but
that Hollywood, as an institution, all too often sanctions and promotes a
cultural ethos that is debased, degenerate, and inhuman.
There is no more prestigious or universally acknowledged expression
of “official” Hollywood than the Academy Awards ceremony, a highly
publicized annual event at which the elite of Hollywood honors itself,
and gives recognition to what it regards as the outstanding productions
and personalities of the preceding year. At the Academy Award ceremony
of early 2006, institutional Hollywood bestowed its highest honor for
the best original song in a motion picture on a rap song -- if such
sound even deserves to be called music -- entitled “It’s Hard Out Here
for a Pimp,” about the laments and travails of a man who makes a living
on the money brought in by his whores.
Here is a portion of the lyrics of this rap song -- these are the
least offensive lines -- which I’ll try to give in English that is more
understandable than the original:
“It's blood sweat and tears when it come down to a lick. I'm tryin'
to get rich 'fore I leave up out it. I'm tryin' to have thangs but it's
hard for a pimp. So I'm prayin' and I'm hopin' to God I don't slip,
yeah.
“Man, it seems like I'm duckin' dodgin' bullets everyday. Niggaz
hatin' on me cause I got, girls on the tray. But I gotta stay paid,
gotta stay above water. Couldn't keep up with my girls, that's when
things got harder
“North Memphis where I'm from, I'm 7th street bound. Where people all
the time end up lost and never found. Man, these girls think we prove
thangs, leave a big head. They come hopin' every night, they don't end
up bein' dead.
“Wait I got a snow bunny, and a black girl too. You pay the right
price, and they'll both do you. That's the way the game goes, gotta keep
it strictly pimpin'. Gotta keep my hustle tight, makin' change off
these women, yeah”
Is this what Hollywood means by “Art for the sake of art”? Is this
really an exemplary product of American culture? Is this the music of a
healthy society? What does this tell us about Hollywood? And what does
it say about America?
In the aftermath of Hollywood’s prestigious honor for “It’s Hard Out
Here for a Pimp,” no major political figure or leading newspaper raised a
voice of protest or shame. That’s because in today’s America, this rap
song is regarded not as outrageous or perverse, but instead is embraced
as an acceptable, praiseworthy expression of US culture.
Another example of Hollywood’s notion of cultural distinction is a
very profitable and widely acclaimed 2009 motion picture entitled
“Inglorious Bastards.” In this absurdly fanciful production, actor Brad
Pitt plays a Jewish US Army lieutenant during World War II who leads a
team of eight Jewish American Army men whose mission behind enemy lines
is to kill as many Germans as possible, and to kill them in the most
cruel, painful and hideous way possible. Each team member, he says with
joyful pride, must collect 100 “Nazi” scalps, and he tells them that no
prisoners will be taken -- that is, every captured German soldier must
be murdered. In one dramatic scene, a US Army sergeant, who calls
himself the “Bear Jew,” kills a prisoner of war by bashing in his head
with a baseball bat.
This vile glorification of a band of vengeful Jewish sadists was
honored by institutional Hollywood with multiple awards, including an
Academy Award and eight Academy Award nominations. Years of conditioning
by Hollywood filmmakers and American educators had primed audiences to
approve and even applaud the sadistic violence of these criminals in US
military uniform, because the victims are, after all, evil “Nazis” who
deserve to be killed in the most hideous and cruel way possible. Over
the years, Hollywood and American public officials have worked together
to stigmatize Japanese, Germans, Arabs and others as expendable, evil
sub-humans who deserve to be eradicated as vermin.
Hollywood and Washington seem always to be on the lookout for new
nations and nationalities for targeting as “evil,” and therefore worthy
of eradication. Not long ago, you’ll recall, an American president
proclaimed Iran to be an “axis of evil” country, and his successor, the
current US president, tells the world that in dealing with Iran, “all
options are on the table” -- which is an indirect way of threatening
Iran with bombing, invasion, war and even nuclear obliteration.
American motion pictures and television, along with the rest of the
US mass media, play an important role in shaping people’s basic
assumptions about life and the world, in setting social-ethical
standards, and in delineating the boundaries of what’s politically
possible. Together with America’s still very formidable financial,
economic and military power, Hollywood and its products have real impact
on the lives of millions, not only in the US, but around the globe.
Along with the rest of the Jewish-Zionist dominated media, Hollywood
sensationalizes and distorts current events, systematically falsifies
history, promotes debased “entertainment” and perverse cultural
standards, and makes possible the Jewish-Zionist hold on American
political life, thereby enabling Israel’s wars and decades-long
oppression of Palestinians.
Today there is no more important or urgent task than to clearly identify and effectively counter this Jewish-Zionist power.
I want to emphasize here that to deal candidly with this reality is
not, as some claim, “anti-Semitism” or “hate.” We should not, and we do
not, wish harm to anyone because of his or her ancestry, ethnic
background, religion or privately held beliefs. At the same time, we
should not -- we must not -- let smears or malicious name-calling keep
us from affirming the truth, and doing what is right.
We are meeting here this week at a conference that brings together
men and women of diverse nationalities, races and cultures, and with a
broad range of political and religious views. But regardless of our
background, nationality or worldview, and regardless of the particular
passion or cause that most moves each of us, we share a sense of
responsibility for the future of our own nations, and of the world.
We are engaged in a great, global struggle -- one in which two
distinct and irreconcilable sides confront each other -- a world
struggle that pits an arrogant and malevolent power that feels ordained
to rule over others, on one side, and all other nations on the other. It
is a struggle not merely for justice or the well-being of the peoples
of this or that nation or region, but a great historical battle for the
soul and future of humanity itself.
End Notes
1. Interview with Larry King, CNN network, April 5, 1996. "Brando Remarks,"
Los Angeles Times, April 8, 1996, p. F4 (OC). A short time later Brando was obliged to apologize for his remarks.
2. Abraham H. Foxman,
Never Again?: The Threat of the New Anti-Semitism (Harper San Francisco, 2003), p. 251.
3. M. Medved, “Is Hollywood Too Jewish?,”
Moment, Vol. 21, No. 4 (1996), p. 37.
4. Jonathan Jeremy Goldberg,
Jewish Power: Inside the American Jewish Establishment (Addison-Wesley, 1996), pp. 280, 287-288. See also pp. 39-40, 290-291.
5. J. Stein, “How Jewish Is Hollywood?,”
Los Angeles Times, Dec. 19, 2008.
(
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/commentary/la-oe-stein19-2008dec19,0,4676183.column )
6. D. Tutu, “Apartheid in the Holy Land,”
The Guardian (Britain), April 29, 2002.
(
http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/comment/0,10551,706911,00.html )
7. Benjamin Ginsberg,
The Fatal Embrace: Jews and the State (University of Chicago, 1993), pp. 1, 103.
8. Seymour Martin Lipset and Earl Raab,
Jews and the New American Scene (Harvard Univ. Press, 1995), pp. 26-27.
9. A. Lilienthal,
The Zionist Connection (New York: Dodd, Mead, 1978), pp. 206, 209, 212, 218, 228, 229. See also: M. Weber, “A Straight Look at the Jewish Lobby.”
(
http://www.ihr.org/leaflets/jewishlobby.shtml )
10. “Nixon, Billy Graham Make Derogatory Comments About Jews on Tapes,”
Chicago Tribune, March 1, 2002 (or Feb. 28, 2002)
(
http://www.fpp.co.uk/online/02/02/Graham_Nixon.html );
“Billy Graham Apologizes for ’72 Remarks,” Associated Press,
Los Angeles Times, March 2, 2002. “Graham Regrets Jewish Slur,” BBC News, March 2, 2002.
(
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/1850077.stm) The conversation apparently took place on Feb. 1, 1972.
11. Michael Medved,
Hollywood vs. America (Harper Collins, 1992), back cover dust jacket.
12. M. Medved,
Hollywood vs. America (1992), pp. 11, 25, 26, 21.
About the Author
Mark Weber is an American historian, writer, lecturer and current
affairs analyst. He studied history at the University of Illinois
(Chicago), the University of Munich (Germany), and Portland State
University. He holds a Master's degree in European history from Indiana
University. Since 1995 he has been director of the Institute for
Historical Review, an independent, public interest research, educational
and publishing center in southern California that works to promote
peace, understanding and justice through greater public awareness of the
past.
http://www.ihr.org/hollywoodagenda_weber.html